BLOG
A collection of article and ideas that help Smart Marketers to become Smarter
Marketing Canvas - Proofs
In this comprehensive guide, we explore the concept of "proofs" in marketing - the crucial elements that make your value proposition compelling and credible. We delve into various types of proofs such as studies, expert recognition, social proof, and certifications, demonstrating how each contributes to a solid marketing strategy. To illustrate this concept, we look at a real-world example of a company that successfully utilized proofs. The guide also includes a unique framework for evaluating and improving your proofs, helping you fine-tune your marketing strategy. Whether you're a seasoned marketer or an entrepreneur starting your marketing journey, this guide provides practical insights that can enhance your marketing effectiveness.
Last update: 8/11/2024
In a nutshell
The Proofs sub-dimension in the Marketing Canvas focuses on the evidence and validation that support your value proposition. Proofs help build trust and credibility by demonstrating how your offering delivers on its promises, reducing customer uncertainty and reinforcing your brand’s reputation. This evidence may include testimonials, case studies, certifications, third-party endorsements, and other trust-building tools.
For example, Green Clean might use certifications like "Certified Organic" or endorsements from environmental organizations to validate its claims of sustainability and safety, reassuring customers of its commitment to quality and eco-conscious practices.
Introduction
The Proofs sub-dimension is a vital element of the Value Proposition category in the Marketing Canvas. It addresses the need to substantiate your claims with clear and credible evidence. In an age of increasing skepticism, especially around sustainability claims, providing proof is critical to gaining customer trust, avoiding greenwashing, and reinforcing your brand's reputation.
Proofs help bridge the gap between what a brand promises and what customers believe, ensuring alignment and confidence in your value proposition.
What are proofs?
Proofs are the tangible and credible elements that validate your value proposition, providing customers with the confidence to trust and invest in your offering. These can include:
Operational Context: Demonstrations, examples, or case studies that show your value proposition in action.
Clarification Tools: Detailed explanations, technical specifications, or visual aids that reassure customers about your product or service.
Third-Party Endorsements: Recognized certifications, awards, or endorsements from trusted authorities.
Brand Reputation: References to your brand’s history, achievements, or well-known attributes.
Greenwashing Avoidance: Ensuring that your claims are transparent, accurate, and verifiable.
For instance, Green Clean might showcase customer testimonials, certifications like “EcoCert,” and its long-standing reputation for sustainable innovation to provide robust proof of its eco-friendly claims.
Laurent Bouty - Marketing Canvas Method - Proofs
Proofs: an in-depth perspective
To effectively reinforce your value proposition, your proofs must:
Show Operational Relevance: Provide real-world examples or demonstrations of how your product delivers value.
Reassure Through Clarity: Offer clear explanations or visualizations that address customer concerns.
Leverage Trusted Endorsements: Highlight third-party validations or certifications that strengthen credibility.
Reference Brand Reputation: Connect your value proposition to widely acknowledged elements of your brand’s history or achievements.
Maintain Integrity: Ensure your claims are truthful, avoiding exaggeration or greenwashing.
For example:
Operational Context: Green Clean shares a case study showing how its products helped a customer reduce household toxins by 80%.
Third-Party Endorsements: Certifications like “Leaping Bunny” verify its cruelty-free claims.
Reputation: Green Clean highlights its recognition as a leader in sustainable cleaning solutions.
Translating proofs into action
Providing proof requires an intentional strategy to communicate and display evidence across all customer touchpoints. From marketing materials to customer service, every interaction should reinforce your value proposition with credible and relevant proof points.
Questions to consider:
Have you demonstrated your value proposition in an operational context that customers can easily relate to?
Have you clarified how your value proposition works to reassure potential customers?
Are your claims backed by trusted third-party endorsements?
Do you reference widely acknowledged elements of your brand’s reputation to reinforce your value proposition?
Are you transparent in your claims, ensuring you avoid any perception of greenwashing?
Statements for self-assessment
For a comprehensive evaluation of your understanding and application of the Proofs concept, rate your agreement with the following statements on a scale from -3 (completely disagree) to +3 (completely agree):
You have presented your value proposition in an operational context that makes it possible to see the promised benefit(s).
You have provided elements to clarify exactly how the value proposition operates and reassure the customer.
Your value proposition is supported by means of a recognized third party: i.e., a celebrity ambassador, a label, or other trusted sources.
Your value proposition has made a direct reference to a widely acknowledged element of your brand's reputation.
Your value proposition avoids any form of Greenwashing.
Interpretation of the scores
Negative scores (-1 to -3): Negative scores indicate a lack of sufficient or credible proof to support your value proposition. Customers may be skeptical of your claims, leading to reduced trust and missed opportunities to build loyalty. Immediate steps are needed to integrate credible and transparent evidence into your messaging.
A score of zero (0): A neutral score reflects uncertainty or incomplete application of proof elements. While you may provide some evidence, it is not compelling or consistent enough to fully reassure customers. Further development of proof strategies is necessary to strengthen customer trust and confidence.
Positive scores (+1 to +3): Positive scores suggest that your value proposition is well-supported by clear, credible, and impactful proof elements. Your evidence reassures customers, leverages third-party endorsements, aligns with your brand’s reputation, and avoids greenwashing. This strengthens customer trust and reinforces your value proposition.
Case study: Green Clean’s proofs
Misaligned understanding (-3, -2, -1): Green Clean fails to provide sufficient proof to support its claims, relying only on vague or generic statements. Without tangible evidence, such as certifications or case studies, customers are left skeptical of its eco-friendly promises, weakening trust and reducing purchase intent.
Surface understanding (0): Green Clean offers some proof, such as basic product descriptions or minimal certifications, but lacks consistency or depth. Customers may perceive the brand as credible but not fully reassured, limiting the impact of its value proposition.
Deep understanding (+1, +2, +3): Green Clean provides robust proof points, including certifications like “EcoCert,” testimonials from satisfied customers, and endorsements from environmental organizations. These elements demonstrate operational relevance, clarify its value proposition, and highlight the brand’s reputation as a sustainability leader, building strong trust and loyalty.
Conclusion
The Proofs sub-dimension is essential for building trust and credibility in your value proposition. By demonstrating your claims through operational context, third-party endorsements, and references to your brand’s reputation, you reassure customers and strengthen their confidence in your offering. Transparency and honesty are critical to avoiding greenwashing and maintaining integrity, ensuring that your proofs reinforce long-term loyalty and advocacy.
Sources
Neil Patel, Dominate your Market, https://neilpatel.com/blog/dominate-your-market/
HubSpot, Principles of Persuasion, https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/cialdini-principles-of-persuasion
More on the Marketing Canvas
Marketing Canvas by Laurent Bouty
Marketing Canvas - Pricing
Discover how to effectively leverage the PRICING dimension in your Marketing Canvas strategy. This guide simplifies this complex topic, providing examples, tips, and a step-by-step approach to enhance your marketing success.
Last update: 24/11/2024
In a nutshell
The Pricing sub-dimension in the Marketing Canvas examines how your pricing strategy supports your value proposition, aligns with customer expectations, and reflects your brand positioning. Pricing is not merely a financial decision but a strategic tool that communicates value, differentiates your offering, and influences customer behavior toward sustainable choices.
For instance, a brand like Green Clean might emphasize pricing transparency and offer incentives for sustainable behaviors, such as discounts on refillable products, to align with its eco-friendly mission and customer expectations.
Introduction
The Pricing sub-dimension in the Marketing Canvas is critical to ensuring your value proposition is both competitive and aligned with your brand’s goals. A well-designed pricing strategy balances customer Willingness To Pay (WTP), perceived value, and cost structure while promoting sustainability. It ensures your offering creates more value than its cost and encourages customers to engage with your brand’s most impactful and sustainable options.
Pricing also reinforces brand positioning by reflecting the quality, exclusivity, or accessibility of your product or service.
What is pricing?
Pricing is the monetary expression of your value proposition, reflecting the worth of your product or service to customers. A strong pricing strategy:
Communicates Value: Ensures that customers perceive the benefits of your offering as exceeding its cost.
Reflects Willingness To Pay: Aligns with what customers are willing to pay for solving their problems.
Covers Costs: Accounts for the full costs associated with delivering your value proposition.
Supports Positioning: Aligns with your brand’s image and goals in the category.
Promotes Sustainability: Incentivizes customers to choose sustainable options.
For example, Green Clean might set a premium price for its eco-friendly cleaning solutions to reflect their unique value while offering subscription discounts for refills to encourage long-term sustainable behaviors.
Pricing: an in-depth perspective
PRICING is a pivotal element of your marketing strategy that requires meticulous analysis due to its complexity and profound impact on value creation. In the Marketing Canvas Method, PRICING goes beyond simply competing with market rates for similar offerings. Instead, it focuses on leveraging pricing as a strategic tool to create or preserve value, propelling your brand upward on the economic value curve.
Perceived Price and the Value Curve
At the core of effective PRICING is the concept of the Perceived Price—how customers interpret the value of your offering relative to its cost. Understanding the standard pricing unit in your market is critical to analyzing your position.
For instance:
In a supermarket, shampoos or soaps are typically priced per milliliter in Europe, while coffee is sold by weight.
In the service industry, consulting services are often charged per hour or day.
Once the reference pricing unit is established, you can calculate the perceived price of your offering compared to competitors using the formula:
24 / (E - C) * (M7 - C) - 12
Where:
E is the highest unit price in the market,
C is the lowest unit price,
M7 is your unit price.
This calculation helps determine your position on the value curve, indicating whether your PRICING strategy accelerates or impedes your business growth.
Example: Artisanal Coffee
Suppose your artisanal coffee beans are priced at $15 per pound (M7). In your market, the highest-priced coffee is $20 per pound (E) and the lowest is $10 per pound (C). Applying the formula provides insight into where your pricing strategy positions you on the value curve.
A strong position on the curve suggests your pricing reflects perceived value, while a weak position may signal the need for adjustment to better align with market conditions and customer expectations.
PRICING and Perceived Value
PRICING is intrinsically tied to how customers perceive the value of your product or service:
If your offering is seen as a commodity, customers will gravitate toward the lowest price.
Conversely, if your unique value proposition is clear, customers may accept higher prices that reflect this differentiation.
For example:
Starbucks customers willingly pay premium prices because they perceive value beyond the coffee itself—a unique experience.
A luxury fashion brand can command high prices because it offers a transformational experience, making cost secondary for its target audience.
Key Principles of an effective PRICING strategy
An effective PRICING strategy should adhere to the following principles:
Be Value-Based: Align your price with your position on the economic value curve.
Consider Market Conditions: Analyze competitor pricing and customer price sensitivity to ensure relevance.
Enhance Your Brand’s Purpose and Positioning: Reflect your brand identity. For instance, a disruptive brand might challenge market norms with innovative pricing.
Strengthen Your Value Proposition: Reinforce the unique aspects of your offering to justify the price.
Ignoring these principles can lead to a PRICING strategy that acts as a brake on your progress, rather than an accelerator.
Assessing your pricing strategy
To evaluate your pricing, consider a scoring scale from -12 to +12:
12 represents a low price that may correspond to a low perceived value.
+12 indicates a high price with a high perceived value.
For example:
If your artisanal coffee is priced above average market rates but customers appreciate its unique quality and sourcing, resulting in a high perceived value, your pricing might score a +8 or higher on this scale.
On the other hand, a low-priced coffee with limited differentiation might score closer to -8 or -12, reflecting a misaligned pricing strategy.
Value Map that helps you understand your current pricing situation
Translating pricing into action
A strong pricing strategy should consistently reflect your value proposition and support customer decision-making. Pricing decisions should be based on insights into customer behavior, cost structures, and competitive analysis, while integrating sustainability as a core principle.
Questions to consider:
Does your pricing strategy create more value than the cost for your customers compared to alternatives?
How well does your pricing align with your customers’ Willingness To Pay for solving their problems?
Does your pricing account for all costs associated with delivering your value proposition?
Is your pricing consistent with your brand positioning and category goals?
How does your pricing strategy encourage sustainable choices?
Method for self-assessment
For a comprehensive evaluation of your understanding and application of the Pricing concept, rate your agreement with the following statements on a scale from -3 (completely disagree) to +3 (completely agree):
Your value proposition is creating more value than the cost of the next best alternative for your customers.
Your pricing strategy is based on customer Willingness To Pay (WTP) for solving their problem.
Your pricing strategy takes into account all costs associated with your value proposition.
Your pricing strategy is aligned with your brand positioning and your goals for the category.
Your pricing strategy encourages customers towards the most sustainable option available.
Interpretation of the scores
Negative scores (-1 to -3): Negative scores suggest that your pricing strategy is misaligned with customer expectations, cost structures, or brand positioning. This can result in undervaluing your product, losing competitive advantage, or failing to support sustainability goals. Immediate action is required to reassess your pricing approach.
A score of zero (0): A neutral score reflects uncertainty or incomplete alignment in your pricing strategy. While some elements may be in place, such as cost coverage or WTP analysis, they lack cohesion or fail to drive sustainable behaviors effectively. Further refinement is needed to strengthen your strategy.
Positive scores (+1 to +3): Positive scores indicate that your pricing strategy effectively communicates value, aligns with customer WTP, covers costs, and supports brand positioning. Additionally, your pricing encourages sustainable choices, reinforcing your commitment to long-term impact and differentiation.
Case study: Green clean’s pricing
Misaligned understanding (-3, -2, -1): Green Clean’s pricing fails to reflect the value of its eco-friendly products, either undervaluing them compared to competitors or setting prices that exceed customer WTP. The lack of cost alignment and sustainability incentives weakens the brand’s positioning and reduces customer appeal.
Surface understanding (0): Green Clean’s pricing covers basic costs and aligns with industry averages but lacks differentiation or focus on sustainability. Customers may perceive value but are not incentivized to choose more sustainable options, limiting the brand’s impact and competitive edge.
Deep understanding (+1, +2, +3): Green Clean’s pricing highlights the value of its unique features, such as non-toxic ingredients and zero-waste packaging, while aligning with customer WTP. By offering subscription discounts and promoting refillable packaging, the brand encourages sustainable behavior. This strategy reinforces its eco-friendly positioning, builds customer loyalty, and ensures profitability.
Conclusion
The Pricing sub-dimension is a strategic tool for aligning your value proposition with customer expectations, brand positioning, and sustainability goals. By creating value beyond cost, basing pricing on WTP, and incentivizing sustainable choices, businesses can enhance their competitive edge, foster customer loyalty, and achieve long-term success.
Sources
Market and Economic Value, Laurent Bouty, https://laurentbouty.com/blog/2019/marketing-canvas-market-and-economic-value
Neil Patel - 5 Psychological Studies on Pricing That You Absolutely MUST Read, https://neilpatel.com/blog/5-psychological-studies/
The Ultimate Guide to Pricing Strategies, https://blog.hubspot.com/sales/pricing-strategy
Replyco, 23 Pricing Strategies Any eCommerce Seller Can Use to Increase Sales, https://replyco.com/brainery/23-pricing-strategies-for-ecommerce-sellers/
More on the Marketing Canvas
Marketing Canvas by Laurent Bouty
Hack: Marketing Canvas and Triple Bottom Line
As Marketers, we are not excused for being complaisant with the world around us. It should have been always the case but today the situation is so critical that we need to take action.
REVISIT STEP 2 - SET YOUR GOAL
The original approach at Step 2 was profit oriented. Indeed, during this step, we recommend to set a financial goal (revenue) before starting step 3 which is the assessment.
The triple bottom line approach (wikipedia) as proposed by John Elkington consists of extending the bottom line concept with sustainable elements. In addition to Profit, Elkington proposed to add Planet and People. The Marketing Canvas Method can be easily hacked for integrating the Triple Bottom Line concept by simply changing the way Goals are set during step 2.
HOW?
At Step 2, you can define goal for Profit (original approach) but also goal for Planet and People. It is not fully clear for me whether a standard framework exists with clear KPIs linking Marketing Strategy and Planet/People elements. You can chose the goals that would specifically work for you when discussing Planet and People topics. Based on a very quick desk research, I identified few topics that could be used for defining objectives for Planet and People. It would be interesting to have your point of views and make this list more robust. Don’t hesitate to comment this post.
LIST OF GOALS FOR PEOPLE AND PLANET
Energy Management: How could you reduce your energy consumption and use more renewable energy when executing your marketing strategy? Goal?
Resource Management: How could you make use of resources for your marketing strategy in such a way that our next generation or in future there are no effects on the resource? Goal?
Waste Management: How could you collect, transport, process or dispose of, manage and monitor various waste materials generated by your marketing strategy? Goal?
Employee Welfare: How could you reinforce employee welfare when executing your marketing strategy? Goal?
Fair Trade: How could you reinforce fairness in your marketing strategy through dialogue, transparency and respect, that seeks greater equity in international trade? Goal?
Cause Marketing: How can you better the society while executing your marketing strategy? Goal?
PROCESS
When you have defined these goals (e.g. CO2), you can apply the Marketing Canvas Method for assessing your current situation (STEP 3). Let’s take 2 examples from the 24 dimensions.:
JOB TO BE DONE (CUSTOMERS): Is the knowledge of your customers’ job to be done helping you from achieving your goals?
FEATURES (VALUE PROPOSITION): Are the features of your value proposition helping you achieve your goals?
By asking these questions, you have interesting discussions about your current ability to achieve these goals (like CO2) or not (Brake or Accelerator).
NEW TEMPLATE
Marketing Canvas Method and Triple Bottom Line